Deutsche Bank believes winning the 13 year West Coast Main Line railway franchise in the UK has significantly increased FirstGroup’s (LON:FGP) risk profile, and has therefore downgraded the stock to Sell from Hold.
This week, FirstGroup beat rival Stagecoach (LON:SGC) and its partner Virgin Rail Group in the bidding war for the lucrative franchise.
Virgin Rail, which is 49 per cent owned by Stagecoach, has run the service since 1997 and will hand over operatorship in December.
In a note, Deutsche analyst Anand Date pointed out that the bid is based on underlying revenue compound annual growth rate of 10.4 percent - 25 percent higher than the latest run-rate of 8.5 percent - which leaves minimal room for manoeuvre if current growth rates slow.
Therefore, although the franchise will initially be earnings enhancing due to low premia payments and capital investment, we see material risk to earnings over the medium term.”
“If revenue growth slows from its 10-year average of 10.2 percent then high fixed costs can very quickly erode profitability. Although this may be tolerable for a short period, cumulative below forecast growth on a 13-year contract would result in material losses over time,” date added.